← Latest
Your Vote, Explained · Both sides
Popular vote compact: for and against
And why it would probably end up in court.
The case for2/5
- The candidate with the most votes always wins.
- Every vote counts the same, in every state, not just swing states.
- The Constitution lets states choose how to award their electors, so supporters say states can do this on their own.
The case against3/5
- The framers chose the Electoral College on purpose. Critics say a change this big needs a constitutional amendment.
- A state's electors could go to a candidate that state's voters rejected.
- Close national races could mean recounts in every state, with no single national system to run them.
The legal question4/5
- The Constitution's Compact Clause says states need Congress's consent for some agreements between states.
- Supporters say this compact doesn't need it. Opponents say it does. No court has ruled.
- Both sides expect a lawsuit if the compact reaches 270. That's where the new Congress could come in.
The compact's backers include people from both parties. So do its critics.
SOURCES · 5/5
U.S. Constitution, Article I, Section 10, Clause 3 (Compact Clause); Article II, Section 1
Ballotpedia: National Popular Vote Interstate CompactargumentsNPR: "Virginia joins a national effort to ensure only popular vote winners become president"AprilCongressional Research Service and law review commentary on Compact Clause consentVirginia
Spot an error? Report a correction →
Get Mid-Atlantic money news every night
Taxes, wages, gov jobs and new laws, explained in a quick swipe. Sources on every post.
Follow @newsspool on Instagram